Rabu, 11 September 2019

THE UPCOMING COOPERATION FOR MARITIME SECURITY IN THE SULU CELEBES SEA

A paper submitted to the Faculty on October 12, 2017.
The contents of this paper reflect my own personal views.

INTRODUCTION
    The Sulu Celebes Sea (SCS), waterway connects the Celebes Sea (Laut Sulawesi/Indonesia) and the South China Sea. It is surrounded by three coastal states (Indonesia-Malaysia-Philippines) which have an obligation to take responsibility for maintaining security and safety of Sea Lane of Trade (SLOT) or other activities which are used for commerce. Refer to the Indonesian foreign ministry, there are more than 100,000 ships pass through the SCS carrying 55 million metric tons of cargo and 18 million passengers estimated per year. It is not only take significant part to economic activity but also source of variety challenges that directly threaten security of the states.[1]
            Successful to inaugurate trilateral cooperation on 19 June 2017 in order to respond current maritime security concerns does not mean that all the threats are manageable. Most of the threats are transnational in nature cause the very dynamic and uncertain situation. It requires a greater cooperation to deal with those situations that might be arise in the future. Therefore, this paper describes contemporary threats and assess future maritime security challenges, then all efforts that have already taken, followed by the factor enabling greater cooperation. It concludes with argumentations of the various concept of upcoming cooperation might take by adopting other successful form and managing additional actors into previous form.

MARITIME SECURITY THREATS
            While the great endeavors of the multilateral forces have significantly reduced incident of maritime crime in vicinity of Somalia and Malacca Straits; in 2016 the International Maritime Bureau (IMB) recorded 191 incidents of piracy and armed robbery on the high seas across the globe, down from the 246 reported incidents in 2015, however, maritime crime activity has intensified in the SCS, with 4 tug boats and 1 fishing vessel hijacked in period March 2016 to March 2017 and total 24 hostages.
“The Sulu/Celebes area is the world’s fastest growing piracy hotspot, with violent attack on commercial vessels and their crews, and an increasingly successful kidnap and ransom business model,” said Gerry Northwood, chief operating officer at armed guard company Maritime Asset Security and Training (MAST).[2]
            The worrying trend in these waters above is a particular concern. Traditional maritime security concern poses a more imminent threat such as transnational maritime crime. One potential trigger for such incident in the future is the remaining terrorist group in the region.  
            Contemporary Threats
Transnational maritime crime involves such economically motivated activity as piracy and smuggling. It provides terrorist and guerrilla groups the means to move weapons and personnel, raise funds and recruit new members. The Abu Sayyaf Group (ASG) has their main base of operation in Jolo and Basilian (the Sulu archipelago) and Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) rebel group has their headquarters in Mindanao are heavily involved in the piracy, kidnapping for ransom, abduct on the crew ships for extortion, smuggling of people, weapons and other contraband across the SCS to sustain its struggle against the Philippines government. They have been engaged in an insurgency for an independent province in the southwestern part of the Philippines for more than four decades.
According to the Regional Cooperation Agreement on Combating Piracy and Armed Robbery against Ships in Asia (ReCAAP) half year report, there were three actual incidents and four tempted incidents of abduct on of crew from ships in the SCS reported from January to April 2017. No incident was reported to the ReCAAP in May and June 2017.[3]

Assessing Future Threats
By 2035, cooperation/convergence among terrorist and criminal organizations and globalized criminal and terrorist networks will become several important trends.[4]  The ASG which involve in global criminal and terrorist networks affiliated with the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) is still the key actor on several terrors in the SCS. They have created maritime threats with growth more serious, violent and complex in the past two or three years. The Indonesian officials said that the ASG was intent to turn the SCS into the “new Somalia”. The 23 May’s crisis in Marawi has proved that the ASG becomes stronger year by year. Fears of the growing reach of the ISIL into Southeast Asia and speculations it could look to the Southern Philippines as a base or territorial foothold in Southeast Asia will be come true. The threat from terrorism will expand in the coming decades as the growing prominence of small groups and individuals use new technologies, ideas and relationships to their advantages.[5]
Also analyzing from ReCAAP half year report, there was no incident reported to the ReCAAP in May and June 2017. Those converging trends are proving that the ASG was postponed their activity for making terror at sea since they had to concentrate their all assets to conduct armed conflict in Marawi. Even though they lost almost 191 group members and withdrew from Marawi, but Philippine Presidential spokesmen Ernesto Abella confirmed that the ASG has successful looted an estimated $1 million worth of money from Marawi. The ASG eased their activities for short time period to reconsolidation, rebuild power and strategize. Strongly believe that they will engage their activities (piracy, smuggling weapons and personnel, raise funds and recruit new members) again through the SCS with new modus operandi and become emerging threat in the future. 


CURRENT MARITIME SECURITY COOPERATION
            After the establishment of ASEAN in 1967, ASEAN countries carried out bilateral military exercises among the members. There are operationalized cooperation endeavors, such pairing as; Indonesia-Malaysia (MALINDO JAYA), Indonesia-Philippines (CORPAT PHILINDO), and Malaysia-Philippines (MALPHI LAUT).
Also in response to the imminent threat in the maritime area of common concern to the three neighboring countries (Indonesia-Malaysia-Philippines) in vicinity of the SCS, in 19 June 2017, they launched a program of trilateral coordinated patrols throughout the SCS codenamed “TRILATERAL COORDINATED PATROL INDONESIA-MALAYSIA-PHILIPPINES (TCP INDOMALPHI)”. There are three Maritime Command Center (MCC) which established at each respective country (Tarakan/Indonesia, Tawao/Malaysia, Zamboanga/Philippines) as coordinating points for the TCP and retain overall responsibility for the tasking and deployment of their respective assets.[6]The activities of TCP INDOMALPHI are:
1.   To conduct maritime patrol.
2.   To render immediate assistance.
3.   To share information and intelligence.
4.   To establish a focal point and hotline of communication.[7]
This is the first significantly operationalized multilateral cooperation in the SCS to develop without an extra regional partner. Nonetheless, several officers who directly involved in the TCP INDOMALPHI said in private that the patrol are often matters more of “show” than of real utility and that it is too early to evaluate their affect on piracy, smuggling and other maritime security threats in the SCS.
            Taken together, these many developments constitute significant progress. Dialogue and information sharing have been enhanced and states seem firmly committed. However, the few operational arrangements that have been created are insufficient to counter the grave maritime threats the region faces.

FACTORS ENABLING GREATER COOPERATION
            The International Maritime Organization (IMO) is defining Maritime Domain Awareness (MDA) as the effective understanding of anything associated with the maritime domain that could impact the security, safety, economy, or environment. The MDA changes to the regional system are enabling greater maritime security cooperation. The changes are summarizing into three key factors: sub-regional power interest, regional economic growth and Malacca Strait Patrol template. These analytical concepts factors are use to describe interconnected and complementary themes present in the developing regional posture.
            Sub-Regional Power Interests
Nowadays, all sub-regional powers that involved in the SCS maritime affairs have aligned their interest toward maritime security cooperation, especially protecting the SLOT from transnational threats.  Most significant among these powers are Brunei Darussalam, Australia, and New Zealand, three neighbors with substantial navies, have also demonstrated commitment to maritime security cooperation in the SCS.
There was Sub-Regional Meeting on Foreign Terrorist Fighter (FTF) and Cross Border Terrorism (CBT) on 29 July 2017 in Manado, Indonesia. Ministers and senior officials from Indonesia, Australia, Brunei Darussalam, New Zealand and Philippines were attending to the meeting which focused on developing and coordinating responses to the threats posed by foreign terrorist fighters returning to, and operating in, the sub-region. The Joint Statement has signed by six countries to acknowledge the importance of whole-of-government responses and the development of national plans of action, as encouraged in the UN General Assembly resolution (A/RES/70/291), including the need to partner with sub-national governments and civil society organizations to counter radicalism leading to violent extremism and terrorism.[8]
Regional Economic Growth
The Regional Economic Outlook for Asia and the Pacific estimates growth for the region to increase this year to 5.5 percent from 5.3 percent in 2016. Growth will remain strong at 5.4 percent in 2018, as the region continues to be the leader of global growth.[9]“Particularly in ASEAN, it will remains healthy in Q3 2017, after GDP recorded the best performance since Q3 2013 in Q2,” said Angela Bouzanis, Senior Economies at Focus Economics analysis and forecast.[10]
Economic growth is the fundamental to gain availability resources necessary to sustain the deployment of maritime forces, and in some cases even expand the capabilities. Since 2010, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand and Philippines have all taken procurement of new naval ships. Moreover, there was a milestone ahead that some of the procurement has been conducted among ASEAN countries, for instance, Philippines Navy (PN) procured 2 Strategic Sealift Vessel (SSV), BRP Tarlac and BRP Davao Del Sur, from PT PAL Surabaya, Indonesia. PN spokesperson said that those 2 navy ships will use not only for humanitarian assistance and disaster response, but also for naval blockades in Southern Philippines Sea including the SCS where the military is fighting local terrorists. In generally, economic growth in the region is encouraging improved maritime security cooperation.
            Malacca Strait Patrol (MSP) Template.
The Malacca Strait Patrol (MSP) which is undertaken by three littoral state (Indonesia-Malaysia-Singapore) on April 2006 in Singapore to ensure the security of Malacca Strait, is a set of practical maritime security cooperative measures consisting the Malacca Straits Sea Patrol (MSSP) to rename the Coordinated Patrol Malaysia-Singapore-Indonesia (MALSINDO) that have already existed since July 2004, the “Eyes-in-the-Sky” Combined Maritime Air Patrols and the Intelligence Exchange Group.[11]In 2008, Thailand officially joined the MSP to give their contribution in joint patrol as to secure the northern approaches to the Straits.
The Lloyd’s Joint War Risk Committee dropped the classification of the Malacca Strait as a “war-risk area” in August 2006 only four months after the MSP has established.[12]Based on the IMB record the number of piracy attacks in the Malacca Strait dropped from 38 in 2004 to zero in 2011. These facts proved that the MSP has great progress to deal with maritime security issues in the Malacca Strait. The MSP initiative is a great form and a successful example of maritime security cooperation among littoral state to counter maritime piracy and terrorism.

THE UPCOMING COOPERATION
           Taking into account all of the factors above, the various concept of future cooperation might take to be more effective and efficient than previous form are as follows:
Adopting The MSP Form.
It is believing that several issues can be adopted from the MSP. Firstly, the use of air assets from each respective country which bring Combined Mission Patrol Team with one Mission Commander. Secondly, the use of platform information system that operated by MCCs comprising of analysis information system and research tool to disseminate any information very quick, secure and in real time. Thirdly, invite sub-regional power to join the maritime security cooperation. 

Creating Anti-Piracy Combined Task Force (CTF).
This concept is complementary; it will not be eliminating the existing form. The CTF is comprised of ships and assets from every country whose ships operate in SCS. The chain of command should be lead by one of the three neighboring countries in that area of interest alternately every year and have to utilize the three MCCs as coordinating points. 

CONCLUSION
            Maritime security issues and problem in the SCS needs to be addressed quickly. Although states along the SCS have taken significant steps toward improving their maritime security cooperation, the MDA changes are creating opportunities for maximizing maritime security cooperation in the future. As a result, the upcoming maritime security cooperation in the SCS that might take depends on how policy maker will improve their ability to exploit the three key factors: interest among sub-regional power, remain strong regional economic growth that impact to the growing resources available to regional maritime security forces, and opportunity to adopt the MSP initiative which is successful in improving maritime security in Malacca Strait.


[1]Lyndon DeVantier, Angel Alcala and Clive Wilkinson, “The Sulu-Sulawesi Sea: Environmental and Socioeconomic Status, Future Prognosis and Ameliorative Policy Options”, Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, 2004, pp. 88-97.
[2]Keith Wallis, “Shipowners Avoid New “Pirate Hotspot” in Water West of the Philippines,” January 20, 2017, available at http://www.gcaptain.com, accessed September 9, 2017.
[3]ReCAAP, January-June 2017 Half Year Report, available at http://www.recap.org/alertsreports/incidentreports.aspx, accessed September 10, 2017.
[4]Joint Staff, Joint Operating Environment 2035, 14 July 2016, pp. 13.
[5]National Intelligence Council, Global Trends: Paradox of Progress, January 2017, pp. 6-28, (PACOM) pp. 91-99 and pp. 215-221.
[6]Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) TMP INDOMALPHI, Jakarta, Indonesia, 14 July 2016.
[7]Framework of Arrangement (FoA) Trilateral Cooperative Arrangement Indonesia-Malaysia-Philippine on Immidiate Measure to Address Security Issues in The Maritime Areas of Common Concern, Jakarta, Indonesia, 14 July2016.
[8]Senator the Hon George Brandis, “Joint Statement of Sub-Regional Meeting On Foreign Terrorist Fighter (FTF) and Cross Border Terrorism (CBT),” July 29, 2017, available at http://www.attorneygeneral.gov.au, accessed September 20, 2017.
[9]International Monetary Fund, “Regional economic outlook. Asia and Pacific: preparing for choppy seas,” April 2017, available at http://www.imf.org>APD>areo0517, accessed September 13, 2017.
[10]Angela Bouzanis, “Economic Snapshot for ASEAN,” September 19, 2017, available at http://www.focus-economics.com/regions/asean, accessed September 21, 2017.
[11]  The Malacca Straits Patrol Joint Coordinating Committee Terms of Reference and Standard Operating Procedures, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 21 April 2006.
[12]“Malacca Straits Removed from War Risk List,” August 9, 2006, available at http://www.insurancejournal.com/news/international/2006/08/09/71308, accessed September 15, 2017.

Tidak ada komentar:

Posting Komentar

COMMAND BY NEGATION: IMPLEMENTASI TRISILA TNI AL DALAM MEMBENTUK KARAKTER PRAJURIT GUNA MENGHADAPI PEPERANGAN LAUT MODERN

Pendahuluan. Peperangan laut modern di masa depan akan mencerminkan suatu bentuk revolusi teknologi militer yang sangat luar biasa dimana...